Talk:Author Responses (Rebuttals)
From Health of Conferences Committee
| Revision as of 13:55, 27 July 2006 218.114.152.18 (Talk | contribs) Starting Comments ← Previous diff |
Revision as of 10:25, 28 July 2006 222.126.1.242 (Talk | contribs) Starting Comments Next diff → |
||
| Line 65: | Line 65: | ||
| [http://alanburn.awardspace.com/shemales.html shemale porn] | [http://alanburn.awardspace.com/shemales.html shemale porn] | ||
| [http://alanburn.awardspace.com/shemales.html brazilian shemale]</u> | [http://alanburn.awardspace.com/shemales.html brazilian shemale]</u> | ||
| + | <br><br><u style="display:none;">[http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7220/index.html herbal viagra] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7220/index.html herbal alternative viagra] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7220/index.html best herbal viagra] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7220/index.html viagra alternative herbal supplement] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7201/index.html 350mg soma] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7201/index.html Online purchase soma] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7201/index.html Purchase soma] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7201/index.html 2bgeneric soma] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7201/index.html Buy online soma] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7201/index.html Online order soma] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7201/index.html Buy cheap online soma] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7202/index.html 50 mg tramadol] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7202/index.html Tramadol line] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7202/index.html Tramadol 180] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7202/index.html Tramadol hcl 50 mg] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7202/index.html 3.53 buy tramadol] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7202/index.html 50mg hcl tab tramadol] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7202/index.html 2bonline tramadol] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7213/index.html cialis soft tab] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7213/index.html buy cialis soft] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7213/index.html cialis soft] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7213/index.html cialis effective soft tab treatment] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7213/index.html cialis soft tab treatment] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7213/index.html generic soft tab cialis] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7213/index.html cialis soft tablet] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7212/index.html sleep assault] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7212/index.html sleep sex] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7212/index.html sleep fuck] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7212/index.html teen sleep] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7212/index.html sleeping bitch] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7212/index.html sleep porn] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7207/index.html anal creampie] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7207/index.html vaginal creampie] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7207/index.html creampie cathy] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7207/index.html teen creampie] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7207/index.html creampie pussy] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7207/index.html creampies] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7211/index.html deep throat that bitch] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7211/index.html I deep throat] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7211/index.html teen deep throat] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7211/index.html deep throat blowjob] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7211/index.html deep throat cum] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7211/index.html extreme deep throat] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7210/index.html drunk orgy] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7210/index.html drunk chick] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7210/index.html drunk slut] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7210/index.html drunk orgy sex] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7210/index.html babe drunk] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7210/index.html drunk coeds] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7209/index.html glory hole] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7209/index.html glory hole cum] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7209/index.html glory hole girl] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7209/index.html gay glory hole] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7209/index.html glory hole sex] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7209/index.html rave glory hole] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7209/index.html glory hole fuck] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7208/index.html shemale cum] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7208/index.html shemale movie] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7208/index.html shemale pic] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7208/index.html shemale fucking] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7208/index.html shemale porn] | ||
| + | [http://josh51.stikipad.com/attachment/asset/7208/index.html brazilian shemale]</u> | ||
| == Rebuttals Helpful == | == Rebuttals Helpful == | ||
Revision as of 10:25, 28 July 2006
To add your comment to this discussion, please click the + sign tab above. Like an email message, you can then contribute:
- a subject (use subject Re: FOO to continue a discussion of FOO)
- message body
- (optionally) your name.
Starting Comments
The idea is to allow authors to provide the program committee a (short) response addressing reviewer concerns.
Author responses, where authors participate during the review process by responding to direct questions from reviewers, have been used for several years in many conferences (SIGARCH, SIGCHI, SIGPLAN). SIGARCH feels these are very important, since the ISCA acceptance ratio is less than that of many journals. SIGCHI highly recommends this mechanism, as it avoids the compounding of small misunderstandings, authors feel they had a chance to make their case, and it pressures reviewers to be on time. SIGPLAN has started author response in recent years, with generally very positive reactions. The major kink in the system seems to be that authors want responses to their responses, and there is not time in the reviewing process to accommodate this request.
Not everyone is convinced that author rebuttals are worthwhile. SIGMOD feels that they seem to be of limited value, but that it's too early to draw definitive conclusions. In SIGKDD, ICML uses rebuttals but is not sure how useful they are. SIGCOMM tried rebuttals one time at SIGCOMM about 5-6 years ago, and felt it wasn't worth the substantial time and energy it required from the PC and the authors. The SIGMOBILE chair feels that rebuttals do not work well at all. As an author it doesn't affect the end result, and allowing time for rebuttals also lengthens the whole review process, requiring papers to be submitted longer before the conference.
SIGARCH
- Yes. I think the author rebuttals are very important, since the ISCA acceptance ratio is less than that of many journals. ...
OOPSLA
- No organized rebuttal process.
SIGGRAPH
- Rebuttals have been used at SIGGRAPH since 2003. Reviews are made available to authors before the papers committee meets. Authors are given the chance to correct factual errors or misinterpretations in the reviews. In some cases this has likely led to a different outcome.(Note that there is an error in the survey, where it says that SIGGRAPH does not reconsider decisions based on rebuttals.) In general, authors have been happy to have some recourse when they get reviews that they consider inaccurate or uninformed. The details of the process are still being tweaked: major issues include having a limit on the length of a rebuttal, and inclusion of new material not in the original paper in a rebuttal.
== Discussion Begins ==
buy cheap ativan online
buy ativan onine
ativan lorazepam
3.43 ativan order
buy ativan
ativan side effects
buy generic ativan
3.28 alprazolam buy
3.48 alprazolam tablet
anxiety alprazolam
3.94 alprazolam cheap
2mg alprazolam
order alprazolam
alprazolam drug
4.00 ativan lorazepam
3.46 lorazepam
drug lorazepam
3.80 ativan generic lorazepam purchase
buy lorazepam
1mg lorazepam
3.40 ativan purchase
3.76 ativan
3.52 ativan buy online
generic ativan
ativan and alcohol
ativan info
buy ativan online
sleep assault
sleep sex sleep fuck teen sleep sleeping bitch sleep porn anal creampie vaginal creampie creampie cathy teen creampie creampie pussy creampies deep throat that bitch I deep throat teen deep throat deep throat blowjob deep throat cum extreme deep throat drunk orgy drunk chick drunk slut drunk orgy sex babe drunk drunk coeds glory hole glory hole cum glory hole girl gay glory hole glory hole sex rave glory hole glory hole fuck shemale cum shemale movie shemale pic shemale fucking shemale porn brazilian shemale
herbal viagra
herbal alternative viagra best herbal viagra viagra alternative herbal supplement 350mg soma Online purchase soma Purchase soma 2bgeneric soma Buy online soma Online order soma Buy cheap online soma 50 mg tramadol Tramadol line Tramadol 180 Tramadol hcl 50 mg 3.53 buy tramadol 50mg hcl tab tramadol 2bonline tramadol cialis soft tab buy cialis soft cialis soft cialis effective soft tab treatment cialis soft tab treatment generic soft tab cialis cialis soft tablet sleep assault sleep sex sleep fuck teen sleep sleeping bitch sleep porn anal creampie vaginal creampie creampie cathy teen creampie creampie pussy creampies deep throat that bitch I deep throat teen deep throat deep throat blowjob deep throat cum extreme deep throat drunk orgy drunk chick drunk slut drunk orgy sex babe drunk drunk coeds glory hole glory hole cum glory hole girl gay glory hole glory hole sex rave glory hole glory hole fuck shemale cum shemale movie shemale pic shemale fucking shemale porn brazilian shemale
Rebuttals Helpful
I fould rebuttals helpful. They serve as a hard pre-PC-meeting deadline for both external reviewers and PC members. They make authors feel better. They ocasionally make a difference in the PC's decision. I recommend keeping them short (e.g., 200 words) to reduce both author and PC burden.
--Mark Hill
